Eden Arts claims Penrith Town Council and Penrith BID were involved in discussions about Winter Droving’s uncertain future months before the public was told it was leaving and failed to commit the financial support needed to keep the event in Penrith — but both have declined to answer questions about their part in the loss of the festival.
Eden Arts says funding talks with the two organisations left it fearing another financial loss, while Carlisle BID offered £40,000 to bring the event north. A town council grant remained unconfirmed, and the charity claims Penrith BID failed to honour a previous £20,000 underwriting commitment for the festival.
Correspondence obtained by Penrith.Town News from Arts Council England reveals the charity’s account of what happened before September’s announcement, when residents and businesses discovered the festival they had expected to return on 24 October was heading north to Carlisle. Bad weather ultimately forced its cancellation for a second year.
Both Penrith organisations declined to comment on the funding claims, when they knew the festival could leave or what they did to retain it.
Concerns about Winter Droving’s future had been raised months earlier. In May, when Eden Arts announced its return following the previous year’s weather cancellation, Penrith.Town reported that its future had already been questioned through the Penrith Place Action Group, whose membership included the BID, town council, Westmorland and Furness Council and Chamber of Trade.
By July, Eden Arts was corresponding with Cumberland Council about a Carlisle event, more than six weeks before the move was publicly announced in September.
Penrith BID subsequently said it learned of the cancellation through social media. Earlier discussions show it already knew there were concerns about whether the festival would go ahead in Penrith, although they do not establish when it learned that relocation had been agreed.
Neither the BID nor town council has provided an account of when it first knew the event was at risk, when it learned it was moving or what action it took in between.
Eden Arts had expected the established local funding partnership to provide the investment needed to stage the festival in Penrith. By August, it was telling Arts Council England that discussions with the town council and BID had undermined that confidence.
“Subsequent discussions with Penrith BID and Penrith Town Council have left us significantly less confident that the level of local investment required will be available,” the charity wrote.
“This would leave Eden Arts carrying an unacceptable level of financial risk.”
Its original funding application included £5,000 from Penrith Town Council and £5,000 from Penrith BID. The charity said the BID’s contribution was confirmed for a Penrith event, while the town council’s contribution had not subsequently been confirmed.
The council has not explained whether the £5,000 application was approved, refused or remained undecided when Eden Arts chose to relocate, or what assurances the charity had been given.
When the move was announced, the council expressed disappointment and highlighted its longstanding financial support for Winter Droving, including annual £5,000 awards through its Signature Events Grant Scheme since 2023.
For Penrith BID, the funding dispute stretches back to the previous year’s cancelled festival.
Eden Arts says the BID agreed £20,000 in underwriting but did not honour that commitment as expected. After the festival was called off, the charity says it tried to meet the BID part-way by requesting £13,000 rather than the full £20,000.
According to Eden Arts, it ultimately received £5,000 linked to its subsequent participation in the BID’s Sparkle Christmas event. Delivering that additional activity itself cost approximately £5,000, the charity says.
Eden Arts also reported a separate unpaid sponsorship commitment, leaving it carrying losses from the cancellation. Its board said those losses affected how much risk it was prepared to take on another festival.
The BID has not responded to the charity’s account or explained the terms of the underwriting, including whether cancellation was covered. Those terms have not been independently established.
While the Penrith funding position remained uncertain, Carlisle BID offered £40,000 on condition that the event took place in the city.
By early August, Eden Arts was seeking urgent discussions with Arts Council England about relocating Winter Droving “from this year onwards”. Carlisle’s offer was already part of the proposal, which the charity presented as an opportunity to secure the festival and develop a longer-term partnership.
A formal request to change the location followed almost a month before the public announcement. By late August, Eden Arts said Carlisle BID had unanimously committed its contribution and preparations with Cumberland Council covering permissions, road closures, licensing and safety were under way.
The charity also said it was beginning direct communication with stakeholders, was meeting Penrith BID and would brief the town council, Westmorland and Furness Council and community partners before wider public communication.
Arts Council England approved the changes in early September. Residents and businesses were told the following week.
The dates of the local briefings remain unexplained, along with whether the council and BID were given a funding target or deadline and whether they explored a joint package to keep the event in Penrith.
Penrith.Town’s earlier investigation established that no application had been submitted for the road closures needed to stage the festival in Penrith. The application would normally have been required around four months before the event.
The move retained the £65,600 Arts Council award for the revised Carlisle project, alongside Carlisle BID’s £40,000 contribution.
Eden Arts also retained £40,000 of its own investment towards staff and preparation costs already incurred or committed. A £20,000 allocation from its Westmorland and Furness Council core funding was removed from the Carlisle budget; this had been the charity’s own allocation rather than a separate festival grant.
Eden Arts has publicly accepted that relocating was its decision, saying it could not responsibly expose the charity to another substantial loss. It has said a return to Penrith remains possible if a sustainable local funding partnership can be rebuilt.
Then select "Add to Home Screen"